Victoria Shield

The Victoria Shield, donated by Victoria University Debating Society, was introduced in 2000 to replace the Management Cup. The Management Cup was presented by Mr Don Harden, a past President of The Wellington Speaking Union, who, before moving to Australia was very active in local speaking events.

Rules of the Contest

a. Each team shall consist of two speakers.

b. For each debate two subjects chosen by the Host Club Convenor, in consultation with the W.S.U. Non-Debating Convenor, shall be placed in an envelope.

c. A coin shall be tossed by the Chairman and the team winning the toss may choose to select either the subject or the side of the debate. The team with the choice of subject shall then be given the envelope containing the two subjects and shall have oneminute to determine which of the two subjects shall be debated. Thereafter the other team shall have one minute to decide whether it shall affirm or negate the subject chosen.

d. From the time when sides are determined, the Affirmative shall have three minutes preparation before their Leader opens their case.

e. Speaking times shall be six minutes for each speaker, with three minutes reply by each Leader, the Affirmative Leader having the final reply.

f. There shall be one warning bell at four minutes during the main speeches and at two minutes during the Leaders' replies. There shall be two bells to signal expiration of time for all speeches.

g. Interjections from teams and audience shall be permitted, excpet during the Leaders' replies. h. The contest shall proceed on a knockout basis.

Past Winners

1969 22 Club B E Brill and I D Anderson
1970 22 Club W G T Wiggs and T A Roberts
1971 IMPS N D V Cheer and A A Curran
1972 22 Club J A Young and B R Newell
1973 University H Stubbs and H Hancock
1974 Rostrum B O'Connor and I Anderson
1975 IMPS N D V Cheer and A A Curran
1976 22 Club B Newell and J Young
1977 University D Linney and C Falconer
1978 University L O'Connor and T O'Brien
1979 (Hybrid) B O'Connor and R J Smithies
1980 IMPS N D V Cheer and A A Curran
1981 University T. O'Brien and J. Fanselowe
1982 University J Fanselowe and J Allen
1983 Wellington Rostrum C Falconer and H Hancock
1984 University N Sainsbury and J King
1985 University I.R. Rennie and A.P. Stockley
1986 IMPS N. Hannan and M. Gledhill
1987 22 Club J. Fanselowe and N. Sainsbury
1988 University R. Kan and J. King
1989 Motown R. Kan and J. King
1990 Motown R. Kan and J. King
1991 University D. Capie and A. Crawley
1992 University D. Capie and A. Crawley
1993 University D. Capie and C. Walker
1994 University T. Thomson and S. Sampson
1995 University A. Gillespie and N. Miller
1996 University N. Miller and R. Salmond
1997 University Neil Miller and Rob Salmond
1998 University Hamish Finlay and Ryan Orange
1999 University Hamish Finlay and Ryan Orange
2000 University Hamish Finlay and Ryan Orange